(short description of image)APPEAL no. 47

(short description of image)
Appeals Committee
Chairman (short description of image)Bobby Wolff USA
Members (short description of image)Herman De Wael
(short description of image)John Lenart
(short description of image)John Wignall
(short description of image)David Stevenson
BEL
NZD
NZD
GBR

Scribe (short description of image)David Stevenson GBR

(short description of image)
Event
1998 World Championships
Senior Pairs Qualifying
   
(short description of image)
Countries
Italy v Germany
   
(short description of image)
Players
NS (short description of image)Longinotti (short description of image)Resta
EW (short description of image)Schneider (short description of image)Gromöller
   
(short description of image)
Board
Board 10. Dealer East. Game All
ª 10 5
© Q J 3 2
¨ 10 4 3
§ A K J 2
ª J 8 7 2 (short description of image) ª Q 6 3
© 10 7 6 © K 9 8
¨ K 8 6 ¨ A J 7 5 2
§ Q 8 3 § 9 6
ª A K 9 4
© A 5 4
¨ Q 9
§ 10 7 5 4

West
North
East
South

Pass 1¨
Pass 1© Pass 1ª
Pass 1NT All Pass
   
(short description of image)
Result
1NT=: +90
   
(short description of image)
Facts
Play:
Trick 1: ª3, 4, J, 5
Trick 2: ¨6, 3, A, 9
Trick 3: ¨2, Q, K, 4
Trick 4: ¨8, 10, J
The Director was called by East after West had won the ªJ at trick one. East wished to reserve his rights. The flap was not put down and East's comments were audible to West. North/South play Precision Club.
   
(short description of image)
TD's
Decision
1NT plus one, N/S +120. West had unauthorised information from East's reservation of rights, so the diamond return was disallowed: this would have given North/South nine tricks. However, the alert was not acknowledged, so the actual ruling was also based on misinformation, and an assigned score based on an opening diamond lead leading to eight tricks.

(short description of image)
Appellants
E/W
   
(short description of image)
Players'
Comments
East called the Director because there were only two diamonds in the dummy and he wished to reserve his rights because he would have led a diamond if he had been alerted. He had seen the convention card but had not looked at the diamond length. North claimed he had alerted East but the alert had not been acknowledged. He showed his convention card to East. West claimed his diamond switch was obvious.

(short description of image)
Committee's
Comments
The Committee made clear that when there is extraneous information available to a partnership and certain actions may have been affected by this information the Committee has to give the benefit of any doubt to the other side. This does not indicate that anyone has deliberately used the information. When summoning the Director players would do well avoid giving unauthorised information as much as possible, for example by dropping the flap or waiting to the end of the hand. General CoC 16.2. '… the alerted player must acknowledge by returning the Alert Card to his opponent'. The Committee reminds everyone that an alert is not made until it has been acknowledged.
   
(short description of image)
Committee's
Decision
Director's ruling upheld
   
(short description of image)
Relevant
Laws
   
(short description of image)
Deposit
Returned X
Forfeited  


(short description of image) Return to Top of page To main Championship page(short description of image)